Purpose Hypothetico-deductive reasoning (HDR) is an essential learning activity and a learning outcome in problem-based learning (PBL). It is important for medical students to engage in the HDR process through argumentation during their small group discussions in PBL. This study aimed to analyze the quality of preclinical medical students’ argumentation according to each phase of HDR in PBL. Methods: Participants were 15 first-year preclinical students divided into two small groups. A set of three 2-hour discussion sessions from each of the two groups during a 1-week-long PBL unit on the cardiovascular system was audio-recorded. The arguments constructed by the students were analyzed using a coding scheme, which included four types of argumentation (Type 0: incomplete, Type 1: claim only, Type 2: claim with data, and Type 3: claim with data and warrant). The mean frequency of each type of argumentation according to each HDR phase across the two small groups was calculated. Results: During small group discussions, Type 1 arguments were generated most often (frequency=120.5, 43%), whereas the least common were Type 3 arguments (frequency=24.5, 8.7%) among the four types of arguments. Conclusion: The results of this study revealed that the students predominantly made claims without proper justifications; they often omitted data for supporting their claims or did not provide warrants to connect the claims and data. The findings suggest instructional interventions to enhance the quality of medical students’ arguments in PBL, including promoting students’ comprehension of the structure of argumentation for HDR processes and questioning.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Staged-release problem-based learning revitalizes medical students' intrinsic motivation and clinical reasoning Yasir Hassan Elhassan, Judith M. Sieben, S. Eleonore Köhler, Desirée Joosten-ten Brinke, Diana H. J. M. Dolmans Medical Teacher.2026; 48(7): 1180. CrossRef
Process-Oriented Analysis of Knowledge Construction in Problem-Based Learning: A Systematic Review of Health Professions Education in Literature Weichao Chen, Binbin Zheng Teaching and Learning in Medicine.2025; : 1. CrossRef
From Bainbridge to bedside: applying automation insights to medical curriculum and assignment design in the artificial intelligence era Sangzin Ahn Korean Journal of Medical Education.2025; 37(4): 519. CrossRef
What are students’ argumentation levels and the effect of argumentation, during HDR process in PBL, on their academic achievements in biochemistry education? Tuğçe Günter Journal of Biological Education.2024; 58(5): 1065. CrossRef
Argümantasyonla Desteklenmiş PDÖ Yaklaşımında HDR Modeli Kullanılarak Geliştirilen Senaryolarla İlgili Öğrenci Görüşleri Nelerdir?: Nöroendokrin Tuğçe Günter Journal of Higher Education and Science.2024; 14(2): 366. CrossRef
La argumentación en la enseñanza de las ciencias médicas Andrea Catalina Nassar Tobón EDU REVIEW. International Education and Learning Review / Revista Internacional de Educación y Aprendizaje.2023; 11(3): 251. CrossRef
Does your group matter? How group function impacts educational outcomes in problem-based learning: a scoping review Athena Li, Elif Bilgic, Amy Keuhl, Matthew Sibbald BMC Medical Education.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Comparative Analysis of Course Satisfaction and Student Assessment Results in Redesigned Problem-Based Learning Sejin Kim, Minjeong Kim, Seom Gim Kong, Ho Joong Jeong Korean Medical Education Review.2022; 24(2): 128. CrossRef
In-house Pre-medicine Trained Students: How Faculty Members Perceive Them? Basir Abidin, Noor A Suliman, Tan C Hing International Journal of Learning and Teaching.2019; : 164. CrossRef
The Benefits of Problem-Based Learning as Active Learning in Theoretical Physiology of Autonomic Nervous System Course for Medical Students Behjat Seifi, Enayatollah Bakhshi, Alireza Imani, Sedigheh Najafipour, Azim Mirzazadeh Strides in Development of Medical Education.2017;[Epub] CrossRef
Effect of Argumentation Instruction on Medical Student Experiences with Problem‐Based Learning Hyunjung Ju Korean Medical Education Review.2017; 19(2): 101. CrossRef
First
Prev
