Abstract
PURPOSE
Analysis of the evaluation for clinical performance examination (CPX) using standardized patient (SP) in one medical school was done to compare the evaluations between the staffs and SPs, among the staffs, and among the SPs, and to investigate the correlation between the evaluation scores and the school record. METHODS: Clinical performance examination was done to seventy-nine 4th grade medical students. Checklist was modified from the existing reference and added more items. Three SPs who were non-physician volunteers were trained by authors about what is the disease and how to act the patient and how to evaluate the students.
Three staffs and three SPs both filled up the checklist at the same time right after each student's performance.
RESULTS
Agreements between the staffs and the SPs were relatively high enough in the items of physical examination and management but low in the history taking related items although they were statistically significant. In the evaluation between the staffs and the SPs, the mean scores in the management and overall attitude were not significantly different, but, mean scores in the history taking, physical examination and overall skill were significantly different. Among the staffs there were no significant differences in history taking, physical examination, overall attitude, and there were significant differences in patient management and overall skill. Among the SPs there were no significant differences in physical exam, patient management and overall skill, and there were significant differences in history taking and overall attitude. The correlation coefficients between the evaluation scores and school records, between the evaluation scores and written report were relatively low respectively. CONCLUSION: To increase the agreement rates between the staffs and SPs, more training for the staffs and SPs are necessary
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
- A study on evaluator factors affecting physician-patient interaction scores in clinical performance examinations: a single medical school experience
Young Soon Park, Kyung Hee Chun, Kyeong Soo Lee, Young Hwan Lee
Yeungnam University Journal of Medicine.2021; 38(2): 118. CrossRef - Students’ self-assessment of achievement of terminal competency and 4-year trend of student evaluation on outcome-based education
Sanghee Yeo, Bong Hyun Chang
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2019; 31(1): 39. CrossRef - Effect of SEGUE-based communication education on nursing simulation practice: a quasi-experimental design
Hae Kyoung Son, Dong Hee Kim
Contemporary Nurse.2019; 55(4-5): 330. CrossRef - Effects of Module Development and Role Play Course on Clinical Practice Examination Scores during a 4th Year Clerkship
Kyong-Min Park, Kye-Yeung Park, Nam-Eun Kim, Bong-Kyung Seo, Hoon-Ki Park, Hwan-Sik Hwang
Korean Journal of Family Medicine.2018; 39(1): 23. CrossRef - Holistic rubric vs. analytic rubric for measuring clinical performance levels in medical students
So Jung Yune, Sang Yeoup Lee, Sun Ju Im, Bee Sung Kam, Sun Yong Baek
BMC Medical Education.2018;[Epub] CrossRef - Comparison of Standardized Patient and Faculty Agreement in Evaluating Nursing Students’ Assessment and Communication Skills
Young Ju Kim
Journal of Korean Academy of Fundamentals of Nursing.2017; 24(3): 189. CrossRef - Development and Effects of Simulation Program for Fall Management
Mi Yu, Jong Kyung Kim, Se Young Kim, Sung Hyun Cho, Myung Ja Kim, GyeongAe Seomun
Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing Administration.2017; 23(5): 548. CrossRef - The relationship between problem-based learning and clinical performance evaluations
Sun-A Oh, Eun-Kyung Chung, Eui-Ryoung Han
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2015; 27(3): 195. CrossRef - Predictors of clinical practice examination scores of fourth year medical students after core clinical clerkships
Kye-Yeung Park, Hoon-Ki Park, Jong-Hoon Kim, Hwan-Sik Hwang
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2015; 27(4): 275. CrossRef - Improvement in Clinical Performance of Interns and Residents through Clinical Skills Assessment of the Korean Medical Licensing Examination
Su Mi Kim, Incheol Park, Hoo-Sun Chang, Eun-Cheol Park
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2012; 24(4): 329. CrossRef - Relationship between the Content of the Medical Knowledge Written Examination and Clinical Skill Score in Medical Students
Jee-Young Hwang, Hwee-Soo Jeong
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2011; 23(4): 305. CrossRef - Correlation of CPX Scores with the Scores on Written Multiple-Choice Examinations on the Certifying Examination for Family Medicine in 2009 to 2011
Jung Jin Cho, Ji Yong Kim, Hoon Ki Park, In Hong Hwang
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2011; 23(4): 315. CrossRef - Development of a Multimedia Learning DM Diet Education Program using Standardized Patients and Analysis of Its Effects on Clinical Competency and Learning Satisfaction for Nursing Students
Kyung Sun Hyun, Hyun Sook Kang, Won Ock Kim, Sunhee Park, Jia Lee, Sohyune Sok
Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing.2009; 39(2): 249. CrossRef - Correlations of Clinical Assessment Tools with Written Examinations
Eun Jeong Choi, Sung Sunwoo
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2009; 21(1): 43. CrossRef - Introduction of Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) to Residency Examination
Son Hwan Choi, Suk Bong Koh
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2008; 20(4): 343. CrossRef - Inter-rater Reliability in a Clinical Performance Examination Using Multiple Standardized Patients for the Same Case
Jinkyung Ko, Tai-Young Yoon, Jaehyun Park
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2008; 20(1): 61. CrossRef - The Correlation between CPX and Written Examination Scores in Medical Students
Yera Hur, Sun Kim, Sung-Whan Park
Korean Journal of Medical Education.2007; 19(4): 335. CrossRef - The Correlation between the Scores of Written Examination, the Clinical Clerkship Examination, the Clinical Skill Assessment, and the Graduation Examination of the Medical Students
Suk Bong Koh, Hye Jin Park
Korean Journal of Medical Education.1970; 21(4): 347. CrossRef
